Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts

Friday, 20 January 2012

Video: Brave LGBT Russians protest in Red Square

Video source by 

 


Image gayrussia.eu
By Paul Canning

A small group of LGBT Russians have taken their protest against laws intended to silence their movement to every region - and last night they produced images of their protesting arrest in front of the Kremlin.

Their protest, signaled on social media to happen in another Moscow location, in fact occurred in front of the most famous location in all of Russia. Within seconds they were swarmed by police.

A small group of activists within the past fortnight have protested a law passed in the northern city of Arkhangelsk which effectively bans all gay organising. Supposedly to 'protect children', the law actually bans all LGBT public events and protests and the rhetoric surrounding it is explicitly against the emerging LGBT movement in Russia.

The dolls - Piggy, Stepashka, Fili and Karkushi - at the Red Square protest were from popular children's TV shows and the banners said "Good night, kids!"

Two Russian regions have already adopted the same law and the supposedly 'liberal' city of St Petersberg has voted in favour but has yet to pass the law. It is reportedly under discussion in Moscow and Novosibirsk and some have suggested it may become a federal law.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, 11 January 2012

More arrests under 'homosexual propaganda' law in Russia

Photo: gayrussia.eu
By Paul Canning

Three Russian gay activists were arrested today under the 'homosexual propaganda' law in the northern city of Arkhangelsk.

Nikolay Alekseev, Alexey Kiselev and Kirill Nepomnyaschiy were arrested and have now been charged and bailed while conducting 'solitary' pickets next to a children's library.

Police had previously allowed 'solitary' pickets but two of the group had earlier unfurled a 20m long rainbow flag outside the regional government building without being arrested (see picture).

They had also held similar 'solitary' protests in the city earlier without incident.

Last month five activists were arrested in Kostroma, North-East of Moscow, as they held protests in the third Russian region to pass a law banning so-called 'propaganda' of homosexuality to minors.

In July 2012 the UN Human Rights Committee will consider the complaint of Irina Fedotova against Russia on the legality of the ban of homosexual propaganda in Ryazan, the first such law, where she was arrested in 2009.

A similar case of Nikolai Baev against Russia is awaiting consideration by the European Court of Human Rights. GayRussia is pushing for the court to expedite consideration of this case.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, 30 December 2011

More anti-gay laws, arrests in Russia

By Paul Canning

A third Russian region has passed an anti-gay law banning LGBT organising and public actions. Five activists have been arrested whilst protesting the law.

Kostroma, a region located 300 km north east of Moscow, has become the third Russian region to outlaw so called propaganda of homosexuality to minors.

Similar laws were formally implemented at the regional level, in 2006 in Ryazan and earlier this year in Arkhangelsk. Discussions also took place in the last weeks, in Moscow, and also in St. Petersburg where it already passed the first reading and has been a focus for international protests.

As in the other regions, the law is framed to link homosexuality and paedophilia and supposed to 'protect children'. Regional politicians claim that "such legislation is already operating successfully in some regions of the country" and would 'protect the morals of the family, and preserve the physical, mental and spiritual health of young people'.

Protester in Kostroma. Photo from Gay.By
Activists travelled from St Petersburg to protest the new law, carrying posters saying 'Stop the homophobic law!', 'gays and lesbians – not pedophiles! Deputies, switch on brains!', and 'Deputies, leave alone gays, be engaged in unemployment!' But they were immediately arrested.

Russia's Constitutional Court has already ruled that the Ryazan law does not breach constitutional protections on freedom of expression and assembly in its decision delivered in January 2010 against activists arrested and charged for propaganda of homosexuality in Ryazan.

Nikolai Baev, GayRussia’s acting Leader, said:
“We started challenging anti gay laws in Ryazan in 2009 and this month in Arkhangelsk right after it came into force. We will do it everywhere such laws come into force.”
Nikolai Alekseev, GayRussia’s Founder, said:

“We have no hope in the fairness of the legal system in Russia, such laws can only be invalidated with a decision of the European Court and this is why we brought a case before this Court, Russian courts are only an obligatory but hopeless step.”
In July 2012 the UN Human Rights Committee will consider the complaint of Irina Fedotova against Russia on the legality of the ban of homosexual propaganda in Ryazan where she was arrested in 2009.

A similar case of Nikolai Baev against Russia is awaiting consideration by the European Court of Human Rights. GayRussia is pushing for the court to expedite consideration of this case.

Elsewhere in Russia, Russian LGBT Network reports that at a 'fair elections' protest in the Siberian city of Novosibirsk a gay man who unfurled the rainbow flag was physically attacked. The group says that local police acted properly, protecting the man, but are demanding an investigation of the assault.

The unnamed activist who was attacked said:
"I think that if you sit very quietly and do nothing, then nothing will change."
At the mass 'Fair Elections' protests in Moscow and St Petersberg and elsewhere LGBT activists have been shunned by the opposition to Putin. This has not stopped the pro-Kremlin youth movement Young Guards from attacking participation of "freaks of all stripes" and singling out LGBT participation in the rallies.

In Sochi on the Black Sea coast, a court will consider the refusal of the local authorities to allow a 'Pride House' during the 2014 Winter Olympics. The proposal was refused on the basis that 'Pride House in Sochi' is not allowed as its not a Russian language term.

Such reception centres for LGBT participation in the Olympics began at Vancouver and the forthcoming London Olympics will host a sizable project. Activists say that the International Olympic Committee has already indicated that it will support such a project in Sochi.
Enhanced by Zemanta

2011 round-up: Part five: Backlash and repression

Manifestação contra Homofobia
Image via Wikipedia
By Paul Canning

I'm rounding up the year in a series of posts - in which no doubt I've missed something, so please let me know what I've missed in the comments!

Backlash and repression

A whole new country, South Sudan, was born with a sodomy law and exclusion of LGBT from rights supposed promised to 'all'.

Turkish LGBT groups suffer repeated attempts to legally shut them down and to block their websites.

The increasingly visible LGBT organising in Malaysia suffered a backlash including law change proposals in two states and the banning of events.

An attempt to use gay rights as a 'wedge' issue failed in Zambia as the opposition leader Michael Sata was elected President. Gay rights was also used as a 'wedge' in Zimbabwe, most awfully to divide the Anglican Church leading to Church resources like orphanages closing and children going hungry.

Malawi criminalised lesbians. This was an issue, but a minor issue, in a subsequent aid reduction by the country's biggest donor, the UK. It was mainly the Malawian government's other walk-backs on human rights and a diplomatic spat which caused the UK's change of approach on aid, but it was played up by them as a 'wedge issue' against the opposition with protests against the state of the economy and human rights abuses called 'gay rallies' in state media.

The so-called 'Kill gays' bill failed to pass at the end of Uganda's parliament in May, probably more by luck than design. It has been reintroduced into the current parliament. The bill provoked the biggest international petition drive for LGBT rights ever, well over two million supported different efforts. Activists pleaded for such support to be offered in the context of the general human rights problems in the country, but most solidarity work continued to single out the gay issue from the bigger crisis. Protests against the bill raised, again, the use of development aid redirection from governments and other government-to-government 'leverage' by Western countries in front of and behind the scenes. The atmosphere generated by the bill led to increased government and societal repression of Ugandan LGBT, highlighted by the murder of leader David Kato in January. Three brave Ugandan activists won international human rights awards, including one described as the most important after the Nobel Peace Prize.

There were a series of arrests of gays in Cameroon, followed by convictions including some based solely on people's appearance, not their acts. There was violent rhetoric, organised hunts for gay people using entrapment and the government ended the year proposing a 'tightening' of the anti-gay law.

Anti-gay rhetoric in Ghana's media and agitation by religious leaders over the past few years produced a proposed witch-hunt by a state leader - and subsequent international attention. In the ensuing fallout, local human rights and civil society groups failed to defend LGBT. The year ended with proposals in parliament for further criminalisation of gay people.

Nigeria reintroduced anti-gay legislation which was then extended in the parliament to attack any pro-LGBT human rights organising, potentially fatally undermining HIV/Aids work amongst other impacts.

There were sporadic reports of death sentences for homosexual offenses in Iran but little follow-up on these reports by either media, human rights or LGBT groups due, in part, to issues with verification and dangers to sources in Iran.

Honduras finally acted on the large number of unsolved murders of LGBT in that country, after US prompting. The rate of murders of LGBT elsewhere in Latin America - particularly in Brazil, Mexico and Venezuela - drew little international attention. As did the failure of the international community to support devastated local LGBT in Haiti following the earthquake, though the UN finally pledged a response.

Anti-gay laws were passed or proposed in Russia and in Ukraine. Pro-gay demonstrations in Russia, and in Belarus, were banned and violently broken up - whilst vicious anti-gay ones permitted. Though Russians finally won a European Court of Human Rights ruling that the ban on Moscow's gay pride march was illegal.

There were reports of arrests of gay men in Tanzania, Kurdish Iraq, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia and Abu Dhabi.

The Serbian gay pride march was banned, reportedly for political reasons. The gay pride march in Split, Croatia was attacked, video of which ensured worldwide attention but in the capital, Zagreb, pride went ahead with no problems - and little attention. In Montenegro the government publicly backed LGBT rights.

The fake 'Syrian lesbian blogger' scandal in June created a huge international storm, outraging real activists participating in the revolution there. Local LGBT in the Middle East/North Africa (MENA) region report mixed feelings about the potential outcomes of the 'Arab Spring' for them - in Syria, gays are reportedly divided on participation in that country's revolt. The devastating impact of the Iraq war on LGBT continued to be felt. A new project documented those who have fled to Jordan, but the year went by with almost no media attention to these 'forgotten people'.

A criminalisation attempt in the DRC (Congo) parliament was started then put on hold.

The UK's foreign aid policy relationship to LGBT human rights became the focus of a major backlash following an anti-aid story in a right-wing British newspaper, particularly in Africa and including from some LGBT activists. In a messy PR foul up, the UK was forced to clarify it wasn't planning to remove aid but redirect it.

The so-called 'curing' of LGBT people continued to spread worldwide from its US origins with a backlash in Ecuador leading to closure of some 'clinics' and the discovery of supposed 'conversion therapy' being payed for by Hong Kong's government. In the US itself 'cure the gay' drew both ridicule and outrage, the latter in particular highlighted by a media expose about the suicide of some gay people forced when they were children to go through it and the discovery that a Republican presidential candidate's camp husband was selling 'conversion' therapy.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, 28 December 2011

2011 round up: Part three: Decriminalization of homosexuality and anti-discrimination

Gay Parade 2007, Buenos Aires.
Image via Wikipedia
By Paul Canning

I'm rounding up the year in a series of posts - in which no doubt I've missed something, so please let me know what I've missed in the comments!

Decriminalization of homosexuality and anti-discrimination

We saw an increased impact in 2011 of the work of the UN Human Rights Council, particularly its Universal Periodic Review (UPR) process of interrogating country's human rights records, and other long term work by activists starting to bear fruit in other parts of the United Nations and other international bodies as well.

The passage of a resolution against killings of LGBT at the end of last year, reversing an attempt by the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) and some African countries at halting LGBT progress in international bodies, sparked a global reaction, including demonstrations and novel contact with governments by local LGBT.

It marked the change in approach by Rwanda in particular, which had previously backed off criminalization, with its UN ambassador drawing on the country's experience of genocide to send a message to those claiming that LGBT is not defined or that LGBT don't even exist.

It marked the first sign of historic change in Cuba, which appears likely to culminate in same-sex unions and anti-discrimination laws agreed by the Communist Party next year. The way that other Caribbean countries changed positively on the UN vote on killings also marked a development which continued in several island nations during 2011.

A change of approach by South Africa on the international LGBT rights front, due to internal civil society pressure, led to them proposing the historic July resolution affirming LGBT rights at the Human Rights Council, which then led to the publication of the first UN report on LGBT human rights in December. That July resolution also caused further ripples, including the first public affirmation of LGBT rights by a Gulf civil society group, in Bahrain.

It emerged that the organised backlash against LGBT rights in international bodies, led by the OIC, Russia and the African group, was receiving support from American Christian fundamentalist bodies such as CFAM. The same people who are losing the 'culture war' at home have shifted to intervening in Africa and the Caribbean and various countries repeated their arguments/lies, such as Uganda claiming at the UN Human Rights Council that lesbians and gays 'recruit'. However it was also clear from investigative reporting at UN HQ that many of the no-shows, abstentions or yes votes of various countries during key UN LGBT rights votes was largely down to US diplomatic pressure. This showed how both US and European pressures on LGBT rights is already happening, and working, in a year which saw extensive simplified and often inaccurate reporting on the use of such 'leverage', like the supposed 'colonialist' tying of development aid to LGBT rights.

Four countries committed themselves to decriminalization: São Tomé and Príncipe; Nauru; The Seychelles, and; Northern Cyprus.

In Botswana LGBT launched, then put on hold, a legal push for decriminalisation. and in Belize LGBT started their legal challenge to criminalisation on constitutional grounds. Jamaican law is to be challenged at the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) and the opposition leader called for a review of the buggery law.

In Chile all anti-gay discrimination was banned. Colombia passed an anti-discrimination law which includes prison terms. In South Africa government action began on so-called 'corrective rape', following massive international attention. But in Brazil, passage of a hate crimes law failed due to increased evangelical Christian influence in that country. And in Malawi, the government criminalized lesbians and used LGBT rights as a wedge issue against its opponents.

The anti-criminalization effort at the Commonwealth Summit failed but it did raise the issue widely in media worldwide.

Several former African leaders came out for decriminalization. In her fantastic speech on gay rights at the UN in December, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton pointedly mentioned one, former Botswana leader Festus Mogue. But only the Zimbabwean leader Morgan Tsvangarai offered support for LGBT amongst current African leaders.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, 13 December 2011

Putin to be quizzed over anti-gay laws

Picture of Alekseev's one man protest in Arkhangelsk by GayRussia. Banner reads: “Children have a right to know that great people too, are gay. Homosexuality is natural and normal. Tchaikovsky, Nureyev and others are names of great stories of gay people in Russia”.
By Paul Canning

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin is to be quizzed directly tomorrow over anti-gay laws.

The High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton, told activists today that she would raise the discriminatory laws at the EU-Russia summit.

She received in Brussels a 246,000 petition along with the Presidents of the European Parliament’s Intergroup on LGBT rights, Michael Cashman and Ulrike Lunacek.

Two Russian regions have passed a law which eliminates the freedom of LGBT people to speak publicly and assemble. The same 'anti-propaganda' law is being considered in St Petersberg and reportedly under consideration federally.

In each instance the laws are being pushed by members of Putin's United Russia party. Putin's Deputy Prime Minister has said that lawmakers should consider the bill at the federal level.

Said Polina Savchenko of ComingOut, a St. Peterburg-based LGBT organization:

“If this law is adopted, it would legalize discrimination against gays and lesbians in Russia. All totalitarian regimes in Europe began with similar repressions of the LGBT community. By supporting our struggle against this bill, Europe helps to prevent Russia from sliding into a new totalitarianism”

A small, brave group of Russian activists tested one of the existing laws, in the far-North Russian city of Arkhangelsk on the day it came into force.

Four activists - Anno Komarov, Alexey Kiselev, Nikolai Alekseev and Kiril Nepomnyaschiy - carried posters in front of public buildings which read: “Trans men can be gay. Sexual education to schools”, "Homosexuality is a healthy form of sexuality. This should be known by both children and adults" and, “In this library children are reading books written by gays. Homosexuality is normal.”

The City Hall has already used the law to ban a larger public action applied for by the activists but local police did not arrest the activists 12 December as one-person pickets do not require a permit.

In front of the City Hall Nikolai Alekseev stood with a poster saying: "Children have a right to know that great people too, are gay. Homosexuality is natural and normal. Tchaikovsky, Nureyev and others are names of great stories of gay people in Russia".

Alekseev, GayRussia's Founder, said that they would take the Arkhangelsk ban to court:

“Either the Court will say that the law did not permit to ban our events because it is not obvious to assess in advance the presence of minors in the public place, or it will simply uphold the ban and we will go to challenge it to the Constitutional Court and the European Court of Human Rights."
“We will win either in Russia or in Strasbourg and this law will be defeated in both ways” said Alekseev.

In 2009, GayRussia activists logged a case with the European Court of Human Rights on a similar bill implemented in 2006 in the Ryazan region. The United Nations Human Rights Committee recently said that they will consider the laws next July.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, 28 November 2011

Russia 'starving' detained migrants

By Paul Canning

An Uzbek news source is reporting that detained migrants in a remote centre in Russia are "emaciated, exhausted and unwell" from being fed only bread and water for months.

The same detention centre was investigated by the BBC in April. They found disturbing evidence of neglect, abuse, and overt racial discrimination by officials.

The detention centre is hundreds of miles from Moscow, in the northern Ural mountains.

“The immigrant workers are being taken off trains and brought to the detention centre ‘to ascertain their status’, but often this process lasts for months,” a well placed source employed in Uzbekistan’s penal system told Uznews.net, asking not to be identified.

The source said that those released from the centre fear "even more unpleasant consequences” if they speak out.

Uznews.net quotes a young man, Sodyk, saying that there were around 40 Uzbek workers who were emaciated, exhausted and unwell. Most were aged about 20 but looked much older. Many had had their passports taken away illegally by the local police.
“Every so often they would allow us to make a phone call but only to other parts of Russia,” Sodyk continued. “The food rations for the most part consisted of a piece of bread with water; for dinner they only gave us boiled water.”
The BBC report found refugees living in a collection of rotting mobile homes that had been used by East German labourers in the 1980s.

The buildings were falling apart. In the bathrooms, there were holes in the walls. Many of the rooms had buckets in the middle of the floor to catch the water dripping through electrical fittings in the ceilings. Most walls were warped with water damage.

The buildings were well insulated, but the residents said some bedrooms were bitterly cold when the temperature outside dropped to -30C.

The BBC reported racism directed at the Africans in the camp and locals shouting Nazi slogans at the refugees as they were being interviewed.

Russia's Federal Migration Service's official spokesperson was sacked after he told the BBC:
"What is now at stake is the survival of the white race. We feel this in Russia. We want to make sure the mixing of blood happens in the right way here, and not the way it has happened in Western Europe where the results have not been good"
Enhanced by Zemanta

St. Petersburg: How you can help fight anti-gay laws in Russia?

Image of St. Petersberg gay demo, broken up by police and attacked by fascists, source GayRussia
Source: LGBT Human Rights Project GayRussia.Ru

Many of you have been asking us how you can help to fight the bill in the most effective way. This Press Release aims to answer your questions as well as bring more insight about the context.

In the last few days, GayRussia has been consulting with its activists, other Russian based LGBT activist groups and legal specialists to think of how to best address the current circumstances.

First, you need to know that the bill is politically motivated: Russia’s Parliamentary election will take place on December 4th and targeting LGBT is a way to earn support from religious and nationalist organizations. The bill received support from Valentina Matvienko the former Governor of the city who is now the speaker of the Upper Chamber of Parliament. Politicians in Moscow said that they are ready to implement a similar law in the Russian capital but also at the Federal level.

Second, we want to stress that the ban of the promotion of LGBT rights on the public place is de facto enforced in Russia since 2005. Implementing this law is only materializing what has been a sad reality for years. For several years, GayRussia has been denouncing the absence of freedom of assembly, freedom of expression and freedom of association for Russian LGBT. As a reminder, over 300 public events applied by GayRussia have been banned, LGBT groups partnering with us have been denied registration by the government in several regions, our activists have been often fined, arrested, judged and humiliated. They introduced 20 cases with the European Court of Human Rights and the United Nations. Russian prosecution refused to open criminal investigation against Mufti Talgat Tadjudin, the Governor of Tambov, Oleg Betin, and the former Mayor of Moscow, Yuri Luzhkov, for calling hatred or to kill LGBT people. The Russian Courts even legalized the insult “gomik” (faggot) which was used by Yuri Luzhkov while referring to gays.

Third, we see this law as a "unique" chance for the Russian LGBT community to re-mobilize itself as it did in 2002 upon the attempt to re-criminalize homosexuality and in 2006, on the eve of the first Moscow Gay Pride.

Russia’s LGBT community has historically been divided and GayRussia would like to hope that today’s attacks by politicians in St. Petersburg will serve as a lesson for LGBT groups in St. Petersburg who have been appearing in the media since 2005 arguing that both “gay prides” and “gay marriage” are provocations.

Thursday, 24 November 2011

Western leaders condemn Russian 'gay propoganda' law

Arrest of Nikolai Alekseev at St Petersberg Pride in June 2011
By Paul Canning

Both the British and the American governments have condemned Russia's 'gay propaganda' law.

The law, which has been rushed through the St. Petersburg Legislative Assembly, prohibits so-called propaganda of ‘sodomy, lesbianism, bisexualism and transgenderism, and pedophilia to minors.’ It passed second reading this week but lawmakers have delayed the third reading until 30 November, according to a video statement by Russian lesbian leader Polina Savchenko.

The bill was introduced by Vladimir Putin’s ruling United Russia party and the same law is reportedly being considered by the Moscow region and also federally. It is broadly written, so could potentially ban wearing a rainbow flag badge or even a public presentation about or concert of music by the gay Russian composer Tchaikovsky where his sexuality was mentioned. It also deliberately conflates homosexuality and paedophilia, as have its proponents.

The UK Foreign Office and the US State department condemnations are unusual. Both been been condemned by Russian activists for a perceived acquiescence to Russian anti-gay actions.

Although the State Department did issue a statement after this year's Moscow Pride demonstration was banned and a number of people arrested, including two Americans, they had said nothing about previous Moscow Pride bans, said nothing when leader Nikolai Alekseev was kidnapped last year and when Hillary Clinton visited Moscow in 2009 to unveil a statue of the gay American poet Walt Whitman activists had then appealed to her to use the opportunity to support LGBT rights in Russia - she didn't.

The organizers of St Petersburg Pride asked the US Consulate in St. Petersburg last year to help by screening the documentary, Beyond Gay, the Politics of Pride, which features the differences between several Gay Prides around the world. The Americans refused, and the excuse was:
“We cannot show a Canadian documentary in the US consulate.”
The State Department made no statement following the banning and subsequent arrests at the St Petersberg Pride demonstration in June this year.

The UK Foreign Office said:
The message of this law, that homosexuality is unacceptable, let alone in any way similar to a crime like paedophilia, is wrong.  It goes against European and Russian commitments to human rights, including the guarantee of non-discrimination set out in the European Convention on Human Rights.

The idea that children need protecting from ‘gay propaganda’ is also mistaken.  In the UK we have also had discussions about how to teach children about sex and relationships.  But as Prime Minister Cameron said in 2010  - ‘We need good sex and relationship education. That education should teach people about equality and the sort of country we are – that we treat people the same whether they are straight or gay, or black or white or a man or a woman. It is important that ethos is embedded in our schooling’.
The UK has assumed the Chairmanship of the Council of Europe, which includes Russia, and says that the law will be raised both by the Consulate General in St Petersburg and at the next EU-Russia consultations later this month.

The UK has also initiated condemnatory joint letters from 12 European countries to authorities in St Petersberg.
"The United States places great importance on combating discrimination against the LGBT community and all minority groups," the State Department said. 
"Gay rights are human rights and human rights are gay rights."
Lance Price, Director of the UK-based international LGBT group Kaleidoscope Trust, said that he believed that international pressure on the authorities is working.
"We hope that our government, in conjunction with others around the world, will maintain the pressure," he said.
Nikolai Alexseyev called for pressure on the European Court of Human Rights to speed up consideration of the complaint before the court regarding the first 'gay propaganda' law, in the Ruzlan region.

Interviewed by Doug Ireland in August last year regarding the attitude of foreign governments to supporting Russian LGBT activists, Alekseev said that Russia prior to 9/11 was often criticised internationally for human rights abuses but after, not so much:
"You know, if tomorrow the Kremlin starts to put us in jail, do you think someone will care? Does someone care when human rights activists are arrested? Not anymore. They used to care," said Alekseev. 
"Europeans have experienced the collateral damages of the fight between Russia and Ukraine on the issue of imported natural gas. When Russia switched off the gas to Ukraine, Western Europe started to be cold as well. The Europeans understand that they have limited margin of maneuver with Russia... Human rights activists in Russia are the hostages of this geopolitics. And I am including us in that pot," he said.
Savchenko said of the delayed third vote on the St Petersberg bill:
"This victory is a very small step. The threat to the LGBT community and human rights remains very real and there is still a very long way to go. This delay by lawmakers wins us time to CONTINUE TO PRESSURE our government. We ask you to continue your support by:
  • Requesting your leaders to contact our politicians and speak out against this law
  • Requesting your mass media to cover the issue and approach our politicians for comments
  • Signing the petition on AllOut (www.allout.org/russia_silenced)"
AllOut.org Co-Founder Andre Banks said that their petition, which is directed at world leaders and being used to lobby foreign ministries, was nearing 200,000 signatures:
"It's moments like these that highlight exactly why we launched All Out just under a year ago: to stand with our friends around the world when they’re under attack, and to keep opportunistic governments from playing politics with fundamental rights," he said.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, 22 November 2011

Update: St Petersberg Passes Anti-Gay Law

Image of St. Petersberg gay demo, broken up by police and attacked by fascists, source GayRussia
By Paul Canning

Russia's second city has passed a law banning so-called 'gay propoganda'.

Update: The law passed second reading but lawmakers have delayed the third reading until 30 November, according to a video statement by Polina Savchenko.

The law, which has been rushed through the St. Petersburg Legislative Assembly, prohibits so-called propaganda of ‘sodomy, lesbianism, bisexualism and transgenderism, and pedophilia to minors.’ The bill was introduced by Vladimir Putin’s United Russia party.

The law has drawn worldwide protest, however it has yet to be condemned by any Western governments.

In St Petersberg itself there have been protests. At one on Sunday protesters held up signs saying "I am gay, a human, not propaganda. Milonov [the law's legislative proponent], do not be afraid! " and "I am a lesbian - do not be afraid of me, Babich!" On Saturday at the NGO Forum of the Nordic countries and Russia in St Petersberg activists took over the rostrum - to the applause of some delegates and silence from the Russians and many others (see video).

The St Petersberg law has been widely reported in Russian media.

Two regions of Russia — Arkhangelsk and Ryazan — have previously passed the same law, which have been deemed constitutional by Russian courts despite the chilling of free speech and the attack on LGBT organizing and ability to protest that they represent.

Polina Savchenko, General manager of LGBT organization Coming Out, Russia, described the law as "absurd, both in terms of legal logic, and in terms of plain common sense."
"So what is the real goal?" she asked. "It is clear that adoption of this law would impose significant limitations on the activities of LGBT organizations. Organizers of public events cannot restrict access of minors to any open area; people under 18 can be there just by chance. Consequently, it makes any public campaigns aimed at reducing xenophobia and hate crime prevention impossible.”

“In the name of ‘public interest,’ members of the Legislative Assembly decided to ignore the Federal law, the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the European Convention for Human Rights, Council of Europe Recommendations and other decrees by international organizations, of which Russia is a member. However, no public discussions were held.”
UK Gay News points out that on 7 November, the United Kingdom took over the Chairmanship of the Council of Europe for six months.

Russia is a member of the Council of Europe and both the Council and its European Court of Human Rights has repeatedly found against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. Moscow's bans on gay pride demonstrations have been before the court and the first anti 'gay propoganda' law in Ryazan is also due to come before it. However Russia has previously paid any fines but refused to actually make any changes.

Says UK Gay News:
In the Committee of Ministers during the handover from Ukraine, British Foreign Minister William Hague MP said that the UK Chairmanship will work to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity across Europe.

“Too many people still suffer outdated prejudices, discrimination and violence because of their sexual orientation or gender identity,” he told the Committee of Ministers. “We will work with the secretariat and our partners in the Committee of Ministers to improve all member states’ performance in this area.”

So, over to you Mr. Hague. The repressed LGBT community in Russia needs help.
According to a 2005 poll, 43.5% of Russians supported the re-criminalisation of homosexual acts between consenting adults.

The City of Moscow is reportedly considering a similar 'gay propoganda' law and there are reports of discussions about a federal Russian law.

Renowned Russian gay activist Nikolai Alekseev has called for Russian politicians to be blocked "from spending their holidays in Nice, Cyprus or Spain" and that Russia’s voting rights at the Council of Europe be suspended. He has also said that petitions from the West to Russian politicians are "useless".

allout.org has a petition, which has quickly gathered 100,000 signatures, which is directed to 'world leaders' and which they plan to deliver to Foreign Ministries around the world.


Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, 17 November 2011

Moscow now proposing anti-gay law

Image of St. Petersberg gay demo, broken up by police and attacked by fascists, source GayRussia
By Paul Canning

After two regions and then St. Petersberg proposed anti-gay laws now it is Moscow's turn.

Gazeta reports that the City authorities will adopt the St Petersberg ban on so-called 'gay propoganda'.
"Yes, we plan to adoption of this law in Moscow and now [are] just working on its development,” chairman of the Moscow City Council Committee on Health Care and Public Health, Lyudmila Stebenkova told the newspaper, adding that the committee “commends the Legislative Assembly of St. Petersburg”.
St. Petersburg's authority has already passed the bill through its first reading, near unanimously. The bill is proposed by Vladimir Putin's United Russia party and, analysts say, will help shore up support for the party in a city where its poll numbers have been falling, as the ruling party's have all over Russia.

The bill would generate fines for “public actions, aimed at propagandizing sodomy, lesbianism, bisexuality, [and] transgenderness among minors.” It deliberately conflates homosexuality and paedophilia. The bill bans any LGBT public event, such as the existing film festival, but activists have questioned if it would ban even wearing a rainbow pin or any news reporting quoting openly gay people - or a performance of a Tchaikovsky symphony.

Vitaly Milonov, the bill proposer, says that St. Petersberg is drowning under “a wave popularizing sexual perversion.”

The Russian backlash on an increasingly visible LGBT movement - 52% of Russians are aware of the repeated attempts to stage a Pride march in Moscow - began in the region of Ryazan, south of Moscow, and earlier this year spread to the far-North region of Arkhangelsk. Activists now believe a federal law will follow.

In an angry opinion piece for UK Gay News, the former organiser of Moscow Pride and the most well-known Russian gay activist, Nikolai Alekseev, who travelled to Arkhangelsk 17 November to publicly challenge the anti-gay propaganda law, calls such laws "cheap populism" and castigates his fellow gay Russians for being 'asleep at the wheel':
In this country, you are taken seriously only if you constantly show your teeth.  If you are too kind, people will not respect you simply because they will not be impressed by you.  The basis is fear and not diplomacy.
As Russian politicians like to tell us: “Go to the Gay Parade in Berlin, but not on our sacred land”.  If you are Russian and gay, lesbian, bi or trans, you can only enjoy your human rights abroad.

And this is the problem.

Our Russian LGBT people ... Their lack of motivation to defend their rights is not an act of cowardice; it is an absence of long term vision.  As some start to wake up today in St. Petersburg to fight this law which will soon directly affect them, others will probably wake up when Russia re-criminalises homosexuality. Then, it will be too late.
Alekseev points to:
The European Court of Human Rights’ decision which found Russia guilty for banning Moscow Prides.  Despite the decision which is obligatory, nothing changed.  Moscow keeps banning the Pride.  The Council of Europe stays silent.
And argues for what Russia might listen to from overseas:
You cannot be diplomatic with those who do not even respect their own words.  Russia signed international conventions that no one forced her to accept.  Either the country pulls out from these institutions, or it must respect their rules.
Think what would have happen in 1962 if JFK sent a letter of protest to Khrushchev instead of organising the blockade of Cuba.  Do not forget history?
Alekseev proposed that the EU "hit the Russian politicians where it will be painful for them" and ban homophobic politicians "from spending their holidays in Nice, Cyprus or Spain" and that Russia’s voting rights at the Council of Europe be suspended.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Sunday, 13 November 2011

Now St. Petersberg proposes anti-gay law

009 churchImage by Percita via Flickr
By Paul Canning

Two regions of Russia - Arkhangelsk and Ryazan - have passed laws banning what they call gay 'propoganda'. The laws have been deemed constitutional by Russian courts despite the chilling of free speech and the attack on LGBT organising and ability to protest that they represent.

Now the St Petersberg region wants to introduce a similar law.

The proposed law, introduced 11 November in the legal committee of the St. Petersburg Legislative Assembly prohibits so-called propaganda of 'sodomy, lesbianism, bisexualism and transgenderism, and pedophilia to minors'. The bill was introduced by Vladimir Putin's United Russia party.

Says Polina Savchenko, General manager of LGBT organization Coming Out, Russia:
"By combining homosexuality, bisexuality, and transsexuality into one law with sexual crimes against minors (pedophilia), members of the Legislative Assembly indulge in gross manipulations of public opinion. Their goal – to pass an anti-democratic law, directed at severely limiting human rights in St. Petersburg."

"In the name of "public interest", members of the Legislative Assembly decided to ignore the Federal law, the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the European Convention for Human Rights, Council of Europe Recommendations and other decrees by international organizations, of which Russia is a member. However, no public discussions were held."

"It is also obvious that adoption of this law violates interests and rights of minors. Russia leads the world in the number of teenage suicides, and ignoring the issues of sexual orientation and gender identity can lead to tragic consequences."

"This bill is absurd, both in terms of legal logic, and in terms of plain common sense. So what is the real goal? It is clear that adoption of this law would impose significant limitations on the activities of LGBT organizations. Organizers of public events cannot restrict access of minors to any open area; people under 18 can be there just by chance. Consequently, it makes any public campaigns aimed at reducing xenophobia and hate crime prevention impossible."
St Petersberg is home to numerous groups: The only interregional LGBT organization "Russian LGBT Network"; the largest grassroots LGBT organization Coming Out; the LGBT festival Side by Side; and other LGBT groups.

Savchenko believes that the LGBT movement in Russia has become now become so noticeable that "the homophobic government can no longer ignore its existence. The state attempts to destroy LGBT organizations using legal framework and to discredit them in the minds of the people."

She suggests that there is a real possibility that such a law will follow on the Federal level.

Lithuania in 2009 pass a law to 'protect minors' banning "propaganda of homosexual, bisexual or polygamous relations". After an outcry from its fellow European Union members this was amended to a "ban to spread information that would promote sexual relations or other conceptions of concluding a marriage or creating a family other than established in the Constitution or the Civil Code" and a ban on information that "profanes family values". The Lithuanian government claimed it wasn't discriminatory but since coming into effect the law has only been used once and that is to try to ban the Vilnius Gay Pride in 2010.

The Ukrainian Parliament is proposing establishing a criminal liability for "propaganda of homosexualizm".

Meanwhile, the website GayRussia is polling readers on whether on not to 'out' closeted but anti-gay Russian public figures.

The former mayor of Arkhangelsk recently alledged that politicians in the region use transgender prostitutes and that some members of the regional assembly, which has banned 'gay propoganda', are gay.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, 11 November 2011

Russian gay activist attacked, police look on

Poster by Novosibirsk LGBT activists
By Paul Canning

Russian gay activist Bulet Barantaev has identified one of a group who attacked him and is demanding the police investigate.

Barantaev is the head of the Novosibirsk (the largest city of Siberia) LGBT organization 'Gordo' and was beaten, stripped and had eggs thrown at him after returning from the Mayor's office 10 October after lodging another notice requesting permission to hold a public action. The attackers despite shouting "Oh, you fag!" easily escaped in spite of the presence of police.

Russian authorities are known for refusing such notices but approving those of far-right Nationalists and Russian Orthodox religious groups calling for 'death to gays'.

He found a photograph of the attacker on social media.

Because the authorities knew he was coming to the Mayor's office, says Barantaev:
"The attack itself was inspired by some of the people of the Municipality of Novosibirsk."
Barantaev demonstrations in Novosibirsk are noted for calling for tolerance of gay teens, as well as talking about the prevalence of homosexuality in the animal world.

The public action he was requesting permission for is called "All types of sexuality - are natural."

They planned to provide information about the 2% to 25% of the different species of animals and birds who exhibit homosexual behaviour, and thus prove that homosexuality is a natural phenomenon and not a consequence of "fashion", "propaganda "or" influence of debauchery "on television.

The mayor of Novosibirsk, Vladimir Gorodetsky, a member of Vladimir Putin's party, has called LGBT activists an "abomination."
Enhanced by Zemanta

Saturday, 29 October 2011

Mocking cartoon draws Orthodox ire in Russia

By Paul Canning

Russian gays have upset the Orthodox church with a satirical cartoon. And not for the first time.

Last week I published on how the Northern Russian Arkhangelskaya Oblast [region] had passed a law banning 'gay propaganda' - outlawing support for LGBT human rights, the second region to do so and a move which the Russian Supreme Court has previously allowed. That story was also about the hypocrisy involved, with the former mayor of the capital, Arkhangelsk, Aleksandr Donskoi, saying that many politicians and business people in the city use the services of transsexual prostitutes.

That story was illustrated with the regional coat of arms, which shows the Archangel killing the Devil with a sword.

The cartoon published by GayRussia.ru mocking the ‘gay propaganda’ law reverses this, with the Devil - personifying homophobia - killing the Archangel.

Orthodox homophobes feel themselves insulted by such a “blasphemous, mocking cartoon”. This is the claim of the co-president of the “Narodnyi Sobor” movement, Oleg Kassin, in his letter to Russian General Attorney Yuri Chaika. Kassin wants the website closed down and its owners punished.

Apparently the cartoon “extremely disturbs Christians, humiliates their dignity and insults their feelings”.

The extreme religious nationalists group has used Russian law before to get artists fined. They have an English language website called 'deviant art' which well illustrates their nationalist politics

In 2007 they pushed for scientist Vitaly Ginzburg's prosecution for publicly criticizing the influence of the resurgent Orthodox Church in Russian schools

Fortunately, following previous online attacks which have shut down the website, GayRussia.ru is no longer physically located in Russia, so it can't be shut down by Russian authorities. However its owners are in Russia, so the threat to them is real.

The website has been here before. Another clerical nationalist group previously asked the authorities to investigate a cartoon published on the website picturing an orthodox priest and a neo-Nazi shaking hands.

That cartoon illustrated the sort of crowds which appear at violently anti-gay demonstrations, approved by the authorities in Russia when pro-gay rallies are banned, which call for the death of homosexuals, amongst other things.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, 17 October 2011

Russian politicians ban 'gay propoganda', hire trans prostitutes

Arkhangelsk Oblast coat of arms via Wikipedia
By Paul Canning

GayRussia.Ru reports that in an interview on the Russian TV show 'Russian Reporter' 3 October the former mayor of Arkhangelsk, North-West Russia, Aleksandr Donskoi said that many politicians and business people use the services of transsexual prostitutes.

Arkhangelsk is the capital of the Russian region which just banned 'gay propaganda'. One other Russian region has a similar ban on "advocacy of sodomy and lesbianism".

Last year the Constitutional Court of Russia decided that such a ban on "propaganda" of homosexuality among minors did not contradict the Russian Constitution.

"I talk with many transsexuals who engage in prostitution, they say that most of their clients are politicians and businessmen," Donskoi said in an interview with Don Alexander.
"The politicians have mostly 'sophisticated' demands for sex. They buy things that ordinary people do not buy. For example, Strap - Girls pinned to the members and then f*****," he said.
In June, I published the shocking story of transgender woman Kim, who was born in Arkhangelsk. Forced to move from there after beatings and harassment, she was lured with a waitress job offer in a VIP night club in Moscow. Instead, she was forced into prostiitution in an underground brothel.
"The clients were mostly police and FSS officers, sometimes even uniformed, usually drunk and/or narcotized. They were not only enforcing us for sex, but beating, mobbing, and torturing, just for fun." 
She describes how the representatives of the Russian state would torture her.
"Nightmares still pursue me, and it will be so through all my life…I cannot even speak about such games as ‘submarine’, ‘helicopter’, ‘phone’… "
Eventually she escaped and in the end made her way to Sweden, although she found little welcome there.

Donskoi offered a cynical view of Russian politics
"People go into politics from a lack of love. Politics - a good way to find a partner: immediately increases your value, even if you're fat and ugly."
Donskoi also said that that among the deputies of the Arkhangelsk Oblast (region) Council of Deputies are closeted gay men.

In their report, GayRussia.Ru "recall" that recently Italian LGBT activists have begun to publish the names of homophobic politicians (mainly from Catholic parties) in Italy who "are themselves gay or bisexual, but voted in Parliament against the granting of sexual minorities against discrimination."


Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, 3 October 2011

Video: pro-LGBT rally in Moscow attacked by fascists

Source:



By Paul Canning

A protest rally held in Moscow by a group of activists representing the LGBT, women's, anti-fascist and left-wing movements, ended in a violent confrontation with neo-Nazi groups on Saturday, 1 October.

According to Margaret, a member of the Raduga Association (Moscow), and a participant in the rally the goal of the event was to protest against chauvinistic populism as the trend of the current election campaign involving stigmatisation and appeals for discrimination of the more vulnerable segments of the society.

There is a draft bill restricting women's right to abortion in Russia's parliament and 'gay propaganda' is now illegal in two regions.

The protest was sanctioned by the Moscow government, fascist groups had widely announced their intention to gather at the same place and “bathe in blood” the perceived “enemies of the Russian people”.

One organiser was immediately arrested by the police solely for carrying a (yet unfolded) poster saying “Say No to Discrimination on the Basis of Gender and Sexual Orientation.”

Pic: Zuban_leb, socialistworld.ru
The fascist and Orthodox group, which included several elderly men and women holding Orthodox icons and images of Russia's last emperor Nicholas, tried to pelt the protesters with tomatoes but police held them back.

One older counter-protester said:
“We wanted to see these demons, these beast in the flesh, for ourselves. It is because of them that God will punish the holy Russia and its people. They want to exterminate the holy nation of Russ.”
Younger fascists chanted calls to beat, torture and exterminate gays - incitement which met with little reaction on the part of the police.

 The main slogans of the protesters were: “We stand for the freedom of choice!”, “Free and Safe Motherhood – Children that are Loved and Needed – Happy Families”, “If you say embryo is human, why are women not human for you?” But when gay rights was mentioned police began grabbing people from the rally.

After it was finally decided to curtail the event ahead of scheduled time, to prevent more protesters from being arrested, the activists had to be convoyed by the police to the metro station, surrounded by a raging crowd (see video). The police counteracted attempts by several able-bodied men to punch and kick young women, but several people later complained of bruises and minor injuries.

The main organiser of the repeatedly banned Moscow Pride, Nicolas Alexeyev, noted inaccurate reports of the rally as "First Gay Pride was authorized in Moscow".

"To date, the only LGBT event allowed in Moscow which was applied took place last year in front of the office of Swiss Air Lines."
This followed the bizarre and unexplained abduction of Alexeyev last year, which he claimed the airline abetted.

Alexeyev pointed out that reports of Russian authorities allowing gay events have been used before by Russia to claim they are not banned.

At the last appearance of Russia at the Universal Periodic Review by the UN Human Rights Committee, Russia was asked why they kept banning LGBT public events.

"We do not ban them, there was a gay pride authorized in St. Petersberg" answered the Russian delegation.

Except, says Alexeyev, that what the delegation was referring to as a gay pride event was instead a rainbow 'flash mob' which was not authorised because no one had asked for permission.

"At this time, no LGBT public action had ever been authorized," he adds.

By contrast, Moscow authorities have allowed numerous 'death to gays' rallies.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Related Posts with Thumbnails