Thursday, 19 May 2011

Video: Brazil: Homophobia, religion and politics

"Caution! Religious freedom threatened - Gay Dictatorship in Brazil - Vote against - Say no!" from the blog Amigo de Cristo (Friend of Christ)
Source: Global Voices

By Raphael Tsavkko Garcia, translated by Sara Moreira

Amidst an increasing wave of homophobic violence in Brazil, which puts the country among the world's worst in terms of crime against the LGBT community federal deputy Jean Wyllys, the first openly homosexual member of the Brazilian parliament, has presented a Constitutional Amendment Proposal (PEC) to legalize marriage for same-sex couples.

Meanwhile, recent statements of hatred and prejudice by some parliamentarians, far right groups and religious representatives, who oppose this and other legislative advancements in LGBT issues, have raised a feeling of indignation in the blogosphere.

An article from Jornal Brasil, republished by O Evangelho (The Gospel) [pt], points out that several religious groups, namely evangelicals and catholics, have been opposing what they call the beginning of a “Gay Dictatorship“ [pt], which includes “homosexual “marriage”, the Ministry of Education's supposed primer against “homophobia” (known as the “Gay Kit”) and PLC 122/2006 (the gay gag law), a bill that intends to criminalize any criticism of or opposition to homosexual behavior or to the intentions of the gay lobby”. In addition, these groups favor the dissemination of ideals which are contrary to the advocacy of LGBT rights [pt].

On this matter, Paulo Cândido, writing for the blog Biscoito Fino e a Massa, criticizes [pt] the “lack of arguments” and the “empty rhetoric”  of the “religious right-wing”:
que mal esconde seu ódio e sua intenção de impor a moral de uma religião à sociedade como um todo.
which barely conceals its hatred and intention to impose the morals of one religion on society as a whole.
Robson Fernando, writing for the blog Acerto de Contas, adds [pt]:

Fora a visão utilitária, influenciada pela moral cristã, que os anti-LGBT possuem da sexualidade – segundo os quais o sexo teria função estritamente reprodutiva –, a homofobia e o alegado “direito de criticar a homossexualidade” têm tudo em comum com a intolerância religiosa e o suposto “direito” de alguém discordar que as pessoas possam seguir outras crenças.
Despite the utilitarian view, influenced by Christian morals, that those in the anti-LGBT lobby have towards sexuality, whereby sex has a merely reproductive function, homophobia and the alleged “right to criticize  homosexuality” have a lot to do with religious intolerance and the supposed “right” to disagree with allowing people to follow other beliefs.
The cases of homophobia, however, transcend the churches and temples, and have even reached the political realm. One of the figures that bridges the two institutions is the evangelical preacher and federal deputy, Marco Feliciano. Feliciano was involved in a controversy after using Twitter to make several racist and homophobic statements, as journalist Paulo Lopes mentions [pt], quoting: “we love homosexuals, but we loathe their promiscuous practices”.

Homophobia with parliamentary representation

"I don't discuss promiscuity! A son of mine is well educated and has no risk of falling in love with niggers or gays!" Cartoon by Carlos Latuff, used with permission.
"I don't discuss promiscuity! Any son of mine is well educated and runs no risk of falling for black women or gays!"
Federal deputy Jair Bolsonaro, affiliated with the Progressive Party in Rio de Janeiro, recently became involved in a controversy for defending the right of parents to hit their children to prevent them from becoming gay.

Rede Brasil Atual (Current Brazil Network) summarizes [pt] Bolsonaro's most polemical statements in a recent interview on the comedy show CQC (the video can be viewed here [pt]):
(…) fez declarações homofóbicas em um vídeo exibido pelo programa CQC, da TV Bandeirantes, nesta segunda-feira (28). Para Bolsonaro, ele não correria o risco de ter um um filho gay, pois seus filhos tiveram “uma boa educação, com um pai presente”. Ele também afirmou que não participaria de um evento homosexual porque “eu não participo de promover os maus costumes (sic).
(…) he made homophobic statements in a video broadcasted by the program CQC, on TV Bandeirantes, on Monday (28). According to Bolsonaro, he would not run the risk of having a gay son, because his children had “a good education, with a present father.” He also said he would not participate in a homosexual event because “I do not participate in promoting bad habits (sic).
An advocate for far right-wing policies and a former army captain, Bolsonaro has made a habit of insulting human rights defenders as well as defending torture, but has never been punished by his peers [pt].

Blogger José Márcio Dias de Alencar wrote [pt] an Open Letter to the Deputy:
O senhor, futuro ex-deputado Jair Bolsonaro, representa tudo que o Brasil hoje mais abomina. E todos os 120 mil eleitores que o colocaram em seu sexto mandato são totalmente responsáveis por esse grotesco show de horrores protagonizado em nossa recente democracia. Irônico um ex-militar que apóia e se diz saudosista da ditadura depender tanto da democracia pra viver,  não? São 120 mil pessoas que pregam o racismo, a homofobia e a misoginia.
Sir, future ex-deputy Jair Bolsonaro, you represent everything that Brazil today most abhors. And all of the 120 000 voters who put you in your sixth term are totally responsible for this grotesque freak show starring in our new democracy. It's ironic that a former military serviceman who claims to support, and to be nostalgic of, dictatorship depends so much on democracy to live, isn't it? Here are 120 000 people who preach racism, homophobia and misogyny.
Via Twitter, the actress and singer Preta Gil, offended by the video of Bolsonaro shown on CQC, announced [pt] that she will sue Bolsonaro for his remarks, to which he replied that he had been misinterpreted [pt]. Jair Bolsonaro defended [pt] himself on his website and denied that he had insulted the singer Preta Gil.

On the night of March 29, a group of parliamentarians, among them Jean Wyllys, Brizola Neto, Manuela D'Ávila and Ivan Valente, filed a complaint [pt] to the House of Representatives asking them to take action against deputy Jair Bolsonaro.

Neo-Nazis, Fascists and “Nationalists”

Image by the author of this post.

Neo-Nazis, Fascists and “Nationalists" image by the author
The statements by Jair Bolsonaro caused the desired effect, and in his defense several right-wing groups staged a demonstration in Avenida Paulista and have been organizing others [pt] against the PLC 122, and in defense of the family and the right to hold prejudice.

Groups [pt] such as Ultra Defesa, União Nacionalista (Nationalist Union), RAC Kombat - Rock Against Communism, Carecas do Subúrbio (Baldies from the Suburb), Integralists and Nazi Skinheads, gathered to defend the deputy and “the family” against the “Gay Dictatorship” and the attempts to criminalize homophobia.

After the protest, at least six people linked to extreme right-wing and hate groups were arrested [pt], which led Eduardo Guimaraes, from the blog Cidadania (Citizenship) to comment [pt]:
[os manifestantes acabaram se] deparando com uma contramanifestação de defensores dos direitos dos homossexuais, um ato corajoso e insensato porque, do outro lado, havia criminosos conhecidos e procurados, o que gerou uma dezena de prisões de bolsonaretes. Em nenhuma outra parte do país, neonazistas e skinheads, entre os quais devem estar os que vêm aterrorizando homossexuais na avenida Paulista, teriam coragem de sair assim tão abertamente à luz do sol.
[the protesters ended up] facing a counter-demonstration with defenders of gay rights, a brave and foolish move because on the other side there were known and wanted criminals, which led to the arrest of a dozen bolsonaretes (supporters of Bolsonaro). Nowhere else in the country would neo-Nazis and skinheads - probably including the ones who have terrorized homosexuals in the Avenida Paulista - dare to come out so openly in broad daylight.
A protest, led by LGBT movements and activists from various segments of the left, was organized on the same day and time as the Nazi-Fascist protest, requiring a huge police contingent to separate the two groups.

Federal deputy Jean Wyllys, in a letter published on journalist Leandro Fortes' blog Brasilia, eu vi (Brasilia, I saw) [pt], calls for the “defense of human dignity, (…) a sovereign principle of the Constitution” and states:
(…) o limite da liberdade de expressão de quem quer que seja é a dignidade da pessoa humana do outro. O que fanáticos e fundamentalistas religiosos mais têm feito nos últimos anos é violar a dignidade humana de homossexuais.
(…) The limit to anyone's freedom of expression is the human dignity of others. What fanatics and religious fundamentalists have done most in recent years is violate the human dignity of homosexuals.
Despite this whole scenario, there is hope. The PEC proposed by Jean Wyllys, and other initiatives on the criminalization of homophobia promise not only to illuminate the discussion over legalizing marriage for same-sex couples, but also to promote greater equality between all citizens regardless of their sexual orientation.

The discussions of and movement towards acceptance of LGBT, already taking place both in parliament and in civil society, will be the focus of the next and third article in the series Brazil LGBT Scene Under Discussion.

This post was proofread by Kitty Garden.
Enhanced by Zemanta

1 comment:

  1. TDhe danger has always been the infantile minds of the idiots who have been for centuries trained by the Catholic Church and now the recent evangelical organizations. The wish to force others to act and believe as they do are a disgrace to th rights and individuality of all humans to make their own choices. Sexuality is not a religious issue nor is it a political issue. One must remember that changing the law will not eliminate prejudice or hate. This can only be done through empathy, education and respect for others. Given the current state of the Brazilian nation this problem takes on greater danger for intolerence breeds hate and hate breeds violence. The fight is a long one, nevr ending and eah individual must combat fear and repression in any form. Keep up the good fight for freedom and humanrights


Related Posts with Thumbnails