Thursday, 16 September 2010

In the USA, humane alternatives to detention are desperately needed

CBP Border Patrol agent conducts a pat down of...Image via Wikipedia 

By Alex DiBranco

The immigration detention system is both a human rights travesty and a massive money pit. While we're busy enriching private prison contractors like Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer's pals at Corrections Corporation of America, detainees are separated from their loved ones, can await a hearing for years, and are all too often subjected to medical negligence or sexual abuse. And, please, remember, these are people who are only charged with being in the country without authorization: although the immigration system tends to treat people as guilty until proved innocent, these people have yet to be found to be wrongfully in the country at a court hearing, some are seeking asylum, and there are even wrongfully accused American citizens mixed in there.

With two high-profile deaths on the immigration detention system's record, President Barack Obama promised to implement some real changes to stop inhumane treatment. Instead, the Obama administration kept busy trying (and failing) to defend the government against culpability for detainee deaths.

The most heartening sign we've seen recently that maybe, just maybe, we can expect to see some of that promised change in the detention system came with the announcement that 17,000 detainees without serious criminal records would be released and no further removal action taken against them. Many of these people have strong cases for being legalized through a spousal or crime victims visa, so it makes humanitarian and economic sense to set them free. However, free-and-clear release isn't an option for every single detainee in the system, which means that detention reform remains just as pressing as ever.

 A new report from the Detention Watch Network, Community-Based Alternatives to Immigration Detention, has outlined for Immigration and Custom Enforcement's (ICE) benefit certain reforms that would work better for everybody (except the private prison contractors losing an easy source of cash). This report comes as a part of the organization's "Dignity, Not Detention," campaign, which has a day of action coming up on October 6 where you can get involved.

Among the recommendations, the report states that the alternatives to detention (ATD) pilot program already created — which uses telephone call-ins, ankle bracelets, and satellites to keeps tabs — should be expanded beyond the mere 16,000 out of almost 400,000 detainees currently enrolled. Detainees should be released with a court date or on bail without monitoring, which is permitted in the criminal justice system but virtually always denied immigration detainees, or ICE must provide an actual rationale for refusal, such as reason to believe a person to be a flight risk or danger to society.

ATD programs are not only less expensive and more humane, they've proven highly effective in having participants show up to court dates and be compliant in leaving the country if they cannot make their case, while ensuring that those charged with offenses still have access to medical and legal services, and aren't unnecessarily deprived of the ability to work and be with their families. After all, it's a bittersweet pill to be found okay to stay in the U.S. if you've lost your job and family has entered deep into debt during the months or years you were forced to spend in a tiny cell.

According to the National Immigration Forum, implementing ATD could decrease the cost of immigration detention by half. And since the current cost is $1.77 billion coming straight out of your pocket that could be put to better use, that's serious savings.

Of course, having a humane system is priceless.

Alex DiBranco is a Editor who has worked for the Nation, Political Research Associates, and the Center for American Progress. She is now based in New York City.
Enhanced by Zemanta

1 comment:

  1. In the last four months Jan Brewer has been caught lying, three times and counting.

    The comments made on June 16, 2010, and June 27, 2010, clearly indicates that the Brewer says that immigrants are beheading people in the United States desert. She first ran away from the question and the press when confronted with the question. She finally when to FOX/ FAKE News to recant her lie.

    When Brewer was confronted with the fact the two of her top Advisors (Paul Senseman, Chuck Coughlin) are lobbyist for “Private Prisons” giant CCA she first ran away from the question and the press.

    In an attempt to gain sympathy, she first said her father had died in Germany fighting the Nazi in World War II (which ended 1945) but of course we find out the truth that her father was never in Germany and died in California in 1955. Do you see a trend here?

    Brewer signed into law SB 1070 Bill (Did she even read it?), lied about the crime rates in AZ (even Janet Napolitano knows that all crimes rates went down), and now we find out that she is in the pockets of PRIVATE PRISONS who stand to benefit with the increase Federal jailing, and thus they will pay her back, I wonder if it has to do anything about the fact that her son was transferred to a brand new prison, he was convicted for rape and sexual assault, I guess the fruit does not fall far the tree.

    “Private Prisons Lie”

    “AZ Crime Rates”

    “Father Lie”


Related Posts with Thumbnails